BSA Chief: Software Pirates Face Increased Crackdown
Their most popular lie: The software industry suffers billions in damages from software piracy. - No, that's wrong. There is no damage in the billions. They lose potential profits, but it's absolutely not proven that these would actually have been earned in a different scenario. And even the profits that actually didn't materialize are not damage - after all, there's no right to profits and no guarantee of profits. They can fail to materialize for all sorts of reasons. Software is simply not a thing, nothing that you produce and then steal. Software pirate is anyway a silly word: none of those people stand in front of the software crate with a gun or knife and demand it to copy itself...
I find this arrogant attitude of the BSA and thus also of the companies it represents (yes, that also includes IBM and Apple, who otherwise come across rather positively to me) almost as infuriating as the behavior of the music industry. This silly attitude that you have a God-given right to profits in the billions (because that's what they're talking about with their claim!) and the evil copiers are directly stealing them is nothing but silly window dressing.
Sure, a company that develops something and then explicitly can't market that product anymore because of illegal copies is in a tough spot - and then really does have reason to speak of damage. That has happened in the area of computer games (LucasArts never properly marketed two games because copies were already out there before they even hit the market).
But none of the companies organized in the BSA have such a position. On the contrary, the biggest rip-off artists are in there, squeezing every penny out of customers and not always delivering the quality that customers actually want - software updates that conveniently skip a major release because then you can charge money for the update. Buggy software that eats data, where the manufacturer then refuses all liability for these software errors (just like product liability in the software sector is a foreign concept for many companies in general).
Of course, companies have a right to enforce their contracts - software license agreements included. After all, no one is forced to buy this software. But this general criminalization of your own customers, this constant suspicion that they would always cheat anyway and this ongoing victim mentality especially of the software giants pisses me off.
At heise online news there's the original article.

